What College Volleyball Coaches Actually Look For

After learning the recruiting timeline, the next question most volleyball families ask is simple:

“What are college coaches really looking for?”

The answer isn’t always height, stats, or highlight videos — and it’s rarely just one thing. College volleyball coaches evaluate athletes holistically, with priorities that vary by level, position, and program needs. Here’s what actually matters.

1. Volleyball IQ Matters More Than Most People Think

College coaches want athletes who understand the game.

That includes:

• Reading the play

• Making smart decisions under pressure

• Knowing positional responsibilities

• Adapting quickly on the court

A player who consistently makes good choices will often stand out more than an athlete who relies solely on raw athleticism.

2. Position-Specific Fit Is Critical

Recruiting is not just about talent — it’s about fit.

Coaches recruit for specific needs:

• Height and blocking presence for middles

• Ball control and consistency for liberos

• Decision-making and leadership for setters

• Versatility and six-rotation ability for outsides

An athlete may be very strong — just not what a particular program needs at that moment.

This is why understanding where an athlete realistically fits is so important.

3. Consistency Beats Flash

College coaches watch far more than highlights.

They’re looking for:

• Consistent effort

• Reliable execution

• Composure after mistakes

• Body language and resilience

A great swing followed by poor court presence or frustration sends a clear message — and not the one families hope for.

4. Coachability Is a Major Factor

One of the most overlooked recruiting traits is coachability.

Coaches notice:

• How athletes respond to feedback

• Willingness to adjust

• Engagement between plays

• Respect for teammates and staff

An athlete who listens, applies instruction, and stays mentally present stands out quickly.

5. Academics Matter — Even More Than You Think

Academics play a role at every level.

College coaches consider:

• GPA and course rigor

• Academic eligibility

• Admissions standards

• Long-term eligibility risk

Strong academics expand recruiting options and make an athlete easier to recruit.

6. Highlight Videos Help — But They Don’t Replace Evaluation

Highlight videos are a tool — not the deciding factor.

They help coaches:

• Identify basic skill level

• See positional play

• Decide whether to evaluate further

But coaches ultimately recruit based on live evaluation — at tournaments, camps, and practices. Quality matters more than length. Clear, concise videos beat flashy edits every time.

7. Character and Culture Fit Are Real Considerations

College programs are small, close-knit environments.

Coaches pay attention to:

• How athletes treat teammates

• How they handle adversity

• Interaction with parents

• Overall demeanor

Talent opens the door — character keeps it open.

The Big Picture

There is no single “perfect recruit.”

College volleyball coaches are balancing:

• Roster needs

• Graduation timelines

• Positional depth

• Academic standards

• Team culture

That’s why recruiting looks different for every athlete — and why comparing paths rarely helps.

How Insanity Athletics Helps

Insanity Athletics works with volleyball athletes and parents to:

• Identify realistic recruiting fits

• Understand what coaches value

• Build strong communication strategies

• Reduce confusion and pressure

Recruiting isn’t about being everything — it’s about being the right fit.

Need Help Understanding Where Your Athlete Fits?

We’re here to help families navigate the process with clarity and confidence.